Don’t Study in the US: Part 2, A Deeper Look at the Pros and Cons

by Jessica Stahl - Posts (449). Posted Tuesday, May 17th, 2011 at 10:01 am

Screen grab from Abdullah's interview on the Mizzou international students blog

Screen grab from Abdullah's interview on the Mizzou international students blog

“I believe the education system in U.S. ranked the best in the world, and people who have studied in the United States are offered better jobs with better salaries and it’ll be easier for them to find a job,” said Abdullah Habibzai, a civil engineering student at the University of Missouri in an interview for the “Mizzou” international students blog. “That was my ambition since many years ago, to complete my high education in the United States.”

Studying in the U.S. was Abdullah’s ambition, but must it be yours?

In this post, the second in our series looking at the pros and cons of studying in the U.S., we take a more in depth look at some of the factors that may influence your decision.

Some Research

The top three reasons students choose to study overseas are: (1) Higher quality of education; (2) career improvement; (3) the chance to live overseas, according to the British Council’s Student Decision Making Survey. Prospective students hoping to study in the U.S. in particular prioritized improving their job prospects in the survey.

By contrast, prospective UK students cited better education as a motivating factor, and prospective students in Germany low tuition fees.

We all know that, although scholarships and other aid is available, studying in the U.S. is expensive. Those who choose to study here reckon that the benefit is worth the cost. But that calculation depends on what you hope to achieve with an American education.

Is a U.S. Education Always Better?

Wow if you are planning to study in the US you'll just end up in debts, I rather study here, it's a lot more cheaper...

Found on Twitter

In our previous post we met Arwa and Amna, two young women who chose to pursue their higher education in Pakistan, and discussed their pros and cons for staying at home or studying abroad. Both say they would have liked to study in the U.S., but they are pursuing their goals in Pakistan and admit that studying abroad may not be the right option for everyone.

In fact, Arwa said, for many Pakistani students, studying in Pakistan is cheaper, easier, and better preparation for their chosen careers.

Sebastian had a similar opinion to Arwa’s when comparing education in his home country of Bolivia to that in the U.S. He says there’s a trade-off; a U.S. education exposes you to more subjects and possibilities, but leaves you less prepared for a specific career:

In my country universities don’t offer much out of class college experiences nor have many student involvements groups, they are only teaching institutions. In the other hand, the way academics are presented are totally different. For start, in Bolivia there are no general education requirements so, for example, an economics major like me doesn’t have to take courses like physics or philosophy. That is better in some way because it keeps one focused on the things really important to one’s career only, in the other hand, having “gen ed” helps student open their minds and even gives them the possibility to change their minds before is too late.

Sadia, who is also from Pakistan and currently studying in the U.S., adds that the job market back home is full of highly educated professionals, so an “American degree or verification is not a ticket to get a good job back home …”

Career Relevance

Your comments on our Facebook page

Your comments on our Facebook page (Click to enlarge)

Sadia decided to study in the U.S. because she felt furthered her specific career goals. She is a human resources professional, and wanted to learn more about human resource and project management in a diverse, international workplace.

According to Sadia, a U.S. education may be most appropriate for people wanting to pursue careers that are likely to be highly international. She lists business, consulting, IT and non-profits as some examples.

America was “a good place to study and get the exposure of international community. The biggest advantage is you can get [is to] make a network of people who are all international …”

By contrast, VOA intern Jihye Choi says classmates who studied back home in Korea could have an advantage in building the networks and relationships to help them find a job in Korea after graduation.

Specific Qualifications

There are some careers for which a foreign education is not appropriate at all, particularly those in fields that require specific qualifications. Ryan Pereira from the U.S. India Educational Foundation, which is EducationUSA in India, cautioned students against pursuing a law degree in the U.S. if they plan to practice back home during an an online chat on Rediff.com:

The U.S. first professional degree, the juris doctor (J.D.), provides an education strongly focused on preparation for U.S. practice, with little opportunity for comparative or specialty study. For this reason, and because preparation in U.S. law will not easily transfer toward practice in other countries, the J.D. is usually inappropriate for foreign nationals.

The website myuface.com adds medicine, dentistry and education as careers for which a foreign degree might not qualify you to practice back home.

Perception

In Korea, says Jihye, the name and reputation of your university are important factors in how employers perceive your degree. For Korean students, a well-known university in the U.S. is considered most prestigious, but a name brand university in Korea is given more weight than an unknown university in America.

start with a vision, differentiate yourself and experiences while abroad, learn to sell!

Advice for selling your international degree to employers, from career consultant Hilary Corna

Jihye provides the following ranking of how universities are viewed in the Korean job market:

Ivy League or other universities that Korean knows really well > Few Korean universities which have good name value > other [foreign] universities (since you can prove that you are fluent in English) > other Korean universities

“This is what Malaysian employers are looking for too,” says Shu Wen Teo, a sophomore biology major at Colby-Sawyer, a small liberal arts college in New Hampshire. But she says studying in the U.S. has given her other unique advantages on the job market, which she will use to make up for her school’s lack of name recognition:

If I want to go back to Malaysia and work, yes, I think this will be a disadvantage. That’s why I have to be involved in college activities, and I think I’ll have to use my attitude and my behavior to convince them I’m really ideal for that job if I’m applying for a particular job.

Because now I’ve become more and more not passive – more active – which is not so common among Malaysians unless you study abroad and interact with people from different countries. It will open up your mind – you’re more able to accept other culture differences. I think this is one of the advantages that a lot of local Malaysians don’t have.

Your responses to the question: 'How important is it to study in the US (or anywhere overseas)? Is it necessarily better? Is it the right option for everyone?'

Your responses to the question: 'How important is it to study in the US (or anywhere overseas)? Is it necessarily better? Is it the right option for everyone?'

And exposure to cultural differences may be one of the biggest arguments for studying in the U.S. (or anywhere overseas).

In an informal poll on our Facebook page, 61% of you felt that studying abroad is a vital cultural experience – a much greater number than those who thought studying abroad would guarantee success in life, or who thought studying abroad is not necessary at all.

Check out Part 3 of this series, where we discuss the pros and cons that come along with the cultural side of studying in the U.S.

Do you agree with the pros and cons listed here?  What would you add to this list?  Let us know in the comments!

13 Responses to “Don’t Study in the US: Part 2, A Deeper Look at the Pros and Cons”

  1. [...] In our next post, we’ll look more in depth at reasons you may choose not to study overseas, and how to decide if it’s the right option for you.  Stay tuned! [...]

  2. [...] it feels like most people talk about improving their career prospects or getting a better education when they discuss why they want to study in the U.S., in an informal survey on our Facebook page, [...]

  3. [...] spent the first half of this week getting realistic – talking about the situations in which someone might choose not to study in the U.S. Coincidentally, The Telegraph newspaper published a story yesterday explaining why studying in the [...]

  4. [...] wanted to share this response to our Don’t Study in the U.S. series from a few weeks ago, in which we discussed some of the pros and cons of coming to America for [...]

  5. [...] might remember from our “Don’t Study in the U.S.” series on the pros and cons of studying in the U.S., we discussed the way employers might perceive degrees [...]

  6. [...] Sebastian said: … in Bolivia there are no general education requirements so, for example, an economics major like me doesn’t have to take courses like physics or philosophy. That is better in some way because it keeps one focused on the things really important to one’s career only, in the other hand, having “gen ed” helps student open their minds and even gives them the possibility to change their minds before is too late. [...]

  7. Pau says:

    Thanks for this article! Studying anywhere in abroad is really a life changing experience; but as for me, I don’t really care if the university’s the best… as long as I enjoy the environment. don’t get me wrong, I do accept change, and I love it. but there’s this gut feeling that if I like the environment, no matter how “unsafe” or “boring” it is, I’d go for it. :)

    I also did a post, “Why I Never Considered USA for Graduate Study” here: http://anthroonfoot.blogspot.com/.

    Hope you could also share your insights :)

    • Jessica Stahl says:

      Thanks for sharing this post! Are you from the Philippines then? It’s great that you made the choice that is right for you, and were able to recognize what you want out of your living experience. I do have to say that if you don’t like the urban experience, I’m not sure how you’ll feel about London, but it sounds like you’ve got some great options available to you! Wishing you all the best of luck, whatever you choose.

      • Pau says:

        Hi Jessica,

        Thank you for checking out my post. Yes, I’m from the Philippines. :) Actually for London, I applied at Swansea, which is on the suburbs (more relaxed atmosphere and definitely cheaper– though still expensive in Asian standards).

        Thank you for you comments, and I really appreciate your post :)

  8. Kay says:

    Hey Jessica,

    In case if you could recall, a few months ago I commented on ‘Why Aren’t Americans and International students become friends’ article.

    My rough observation after being in UCLA for 6 weeks (summer session) would be Americans are more inclined to make friends with International students as compared to Australians, despite I have also heard American friends calling international students as fobs, in which Australians are less likely to do that. But again, some American friends of mine have pointed out the reason international students are more welcomed because they can increase the popularity of certain groups to be more ‘diversified’. Was a little surprised when most Americans I have met have little to no clue about the rest of the world.

    Either way, I enjoyed my experience in UCLA, leaving me no regrets. The facilities and education in the US (well, referring to reputable universities) are far better than the reputable universities in the Australia. Students are more opened and in general, well-embraced diversity as compared to (a somewhat conservative country called Australia).

    Best thing I have ever spectate is having an African American, an Anglo-Saxon, an Asian and a Hispanic sitting together for dinner in the dining hall.

    Shu Wen Teo , in fact is my senior who have graduated quite awhile ago while I was completing my high school diploma as she was in the process for admission to Colby-Sawyer. Have heard her putting a lot of hard work and turned what’s impossible for her initially to something possible, and I agree with her. It’s not worth to study in the States nor anywhere else if we were to head back to Malaysia as it takes forever to cover the tuition fees and other costs while abroad using our salary in Malaysia.

    • Jessica Stahl says:

      Thanks so much for remembering that I was interested and following up! I’m really glad to hear that you had a positive experience at UCLA. I’m a little distressed to hear that some Americans called international students FOBs (that’s not a nice thing to call someone), but happy that overall you felt welcome and enjoyed the diversity. It’s interesting to hear the comparison between the US and Australia. Stay well and stay in touch!

  9. Jnan says:

    Education is essential to life.There are so many kinds of education. So many institutions are imparting education and training around the world. But none seems to be imparting the best education. Some institutions impart formal education while others imparts professional education and professional training. Generally,such types of education are meant for jobs that bring good salaries. On the contrary,the crime index is soaring higher and higher.Rivalry,terrorism and competition have created more and more problems in the world. There are so many signs that the world is gradually being pushed towards annihilation in order to fulfill the prophecy for creation of the New Earth and the New Heaven. So many centuries ago Enoch lived on this earth,how did he earn his education ? By dint of his education he did not face his death and God took him away alive. What type of education did Noah have that he was a young chap at his age of 500 years and that after it he had three sons Sam,Ham and Japheth ? What sort of education did the Prophet Eliza have that he did not meet his death and that nobody had the chance to perform his last rites ? They had their education on the Truth of Life. They earned it by dint of personal study,meditation and devotion.Hence,the best education is ”Education on the Truth of Life”.

  10. rajesh says:

    your blog is very informative for medical students to take admission in medical colleges in india For more detail visit . List of medical colleges in india
    Dental council of india
    mbbs bds admission
    Dental council of india
    medical admission

Leave a Reply

The Student Union is…

A place to hear stories about studying in the U.S. Our bloggers have come from all over the world to U.S. universities, and they'll be sharing their experiences, advice and more.

Learn more about this blog »

Share your own story!
Tell us about your experiences applying to the US, studying in America, or doing an exchange, and we may include it on the blog.

Explore

Glossary of Confusing Words

Find definitions of confusing words and terms about studying in the U.S. in our Glossary of Confusing Words.

All the words were submitted by YOU, so visit the glossary to see the words that have been defined already and to suggest your own.